Immigration Reform Would Benefit Ohio Agriculture, But Some Producers See Downsides

Feb 01, 2013

Immigration Reform Would Benefit Ohio Agriculture, But Some Producers See Downsides

Immigrant and seasonal workers, mostly Latinos, are vital to different sectors of Ohio agriculture, such as vegetable production.

TOLEDO, Ohio -- Ohio agricultural producers who employ Latino immigrant workers would favor comprehensive immigration reform for several reasons, according to an Ohio State University Extension specialist on agricultural labor.
Francisco Espinoza, coordinator of OSU Extension's Agriculture and Horticulture Labor Education Program, said effective reform would afford producers a stable, legal workforce of experienced workers, plus newer workers should their operations expand. 
"Replacing the current H2A guest worker program with a more workable, less expensive, less cumbersome visa program would move things in a positive direction for agricultural producers in Ohio," said Espinoza, who is also chairman of the Farmworker Agencies Liaison Communication and Outreach Network (FALCON), a coalition of government agencies and advocacy groups that supports the state's seasonal and migrant farmworkers and agricultural producers.
"Reforming immigration would also address the problem of losing a producer's workforce when they are found to be undocumented, as this is a costly experience in both profitability and legal problems."
OSU Extension is the outreach arm of Ohio State's College of Food, Agricultural, and Environmental Sciences.
On Monday (1/28), a bipartisan committee in the U.S. Senate announced plans for comprehensive immigration reform. The following day, President Barack Obama unveiled his vision for new immigration legislation.
Espinoza noted that the American Nursery and Landscape Association, the American Farm Bureau Federation, and U.S. Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack all favor comprehensive immigration reform. The Agricultural Workforce Coalition of nursery and agricultural interests, he said, would like to replace the H2A guest worker program with a system of yearlong work visas.
However, Espinoza said, some agricultural employers see potential downsides to comprehensive immigration reform. 
"Nationalizing the E-Verify system claims to discover undocumented individuals in the workforce, but the agricultural community is averse to the bureaucracy of government programs and would also not want the burden of being the enforcers," he said. 
"Continued border and immigration enforcement was emphasized as part of any Senate immigration reform plan, but agricultural employers want no part of raids, racial profiling or other interruptions to their operations, seeing them as detrimental to recruiting and maintaining a much-needed workforce." 
Espinoza also pointed out that producers still remember the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986, which provided amnesty to undocumented immigrants.
"The Reagan amnesty resulted in the exit of farmworkers out of agriculture and into mainstream employment, once their adjusted status afforded them the opportunity. A repeat of this would not be a permanent solution (to agriculture's labor needs)."
Migrant and seasonal workers are crucial to many sectors of Ohio's diverse agricultural industry, including vegetable production, dairy farming, nurseries and landscape operations.

Mauricio Espinoza

Francisco Espinoza
My OSU Extension
Lindsay Binegar

“I think 4-H is important even if you don't live on a farm. Whatever project you take-photography, foods, clothing, art-being able to show off what you completed gives you a big sense of accomplishment. It's very important that 4-H sticks around and continues to grow.”

Lindsay Binegar
Highland County 4-H member

Signature Programs

Signature Programs


Ohio State University Extension embraces human diversity and is committed to ensuring that all research and related educational programs are available to clientele on a nondiscriminatory basis without regard to age, ancestry, color, disability, gender identity or expression, genetic information, HIV/AIDS status, military status, national origin, race, religion, sex, sexual orientation, or veteran status. This statement is in accordance with United States Civil Rights Laws and the USDA.

Keith L. Smith, Associate Vice President for Agricultural Administration; Associate Dean, College of Food, Agricultural, and Environmental Sciences; Director, Ohio State University Extension; and Gist Chair in Extension Education and Leadership.

For Deaf and Hard of Hearing, please contact Ohio State University Extension using your preferred communication (e-mail, relay services, or video relay services). Phone 1-800-750-0750 between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. EST Monday through Friday. Inform the operator to dial 614-292-6181.