First-of-its-kind Wastewater Treatment System Saves Turkey Processor Millions, Protects Environment

Nov 19, 2012

 
First-of-its-kind Wastewater Treatment System Saves Turkey Processor Millions, Protects Environment

Ryan Kopp and Karen Mancl pose on top of one of the wastewater treamtent bioreactors at Whitewater Processing Co. in August. The system, the first of its kind, is the result of more than a decade of Ohio State research. (Photo courtesy of Karen Mancl)

HARRISON, Ohio -- A southwestern Ohio turkey processing plant has much to be thankful for this season.

Whitewater Processing Co. slaughters and processes 6,000 to 8,000 turkeys on a normal day, producing about 2.5 to 3 million pounds of turkey in an average month. The Kopp family has run the business since the 1930s, and with 110 employees, wanted to stay put.

But in the 1990s, environmental concerns about the 145,000 gallons of wastewater it produces each day nearly sunk the business.

Today, with a first-of-its-kind treatment system designed by an Ohio State University researcher, the rough waters have calmed.

And though the costs have been considerable -- about $1 million to build the wastewater treatment system plus an estimated $1.8 million to operate and maintain it over the next 20 years -- the Kopp family figures the business will save at least $10 million over the next-best alternative.

"It's working very well, we're very excited about it," said Ryan Kopp, project manager.

In the late 1990s, Whitewater began working with Karen Mancl, an environmental scientist and Ohio State University Extension water quality specialist, after the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency grew concerned about the company's open-lagoon wastewater treatment system, especially with the Whitewater River so close to the facility.

P1050112.JPG
Kayakers enjoy the Whitewater River at the point where treated wastewater from the Whitewater Processing Co. discharges into the river. (Photo courtesy of Karen Mancl)

 

"It's a beautiful river, and we definitely wanted to make sure it's protected," said Mancl, who is also a professor in Ohio State's College of Food, Agricultural, and Environmental Sciences and a scientist with the college's research arm, the Ohio Agricultural Research and Development Center.

The timing was fortuitous: Mancl had just finished a study on using a sand bioreactor system to treat wastewater from a cheese-making plant. Though that company didn't follow through with the system, Mancl's studies showed bioreactors provide an effective way to treat high-fat, high-organic-matter wastewater at a relatively low cost.

Whitewater's options were limited. The EPA first suggested it hook up to Harrison's municipal wastewater treatment plant. But the company would still need to pretreat its water to remove pollutants that the municipal system wasn’t designed to handle, and it would still have to pay a premium to the facility.

The total cost for the construction of the pretreatment facility, hook-up and use of the Harrison treatment plant over 20 years was estimated at $12.5 million.

"And it likely would have been even more," Kopp said. "They had given us some estimates for future increases in treatment costs when we first looked at that option, and so far the actual increases have been more than they projected."

In 2001, Whitewater began funding research in Mancl's lab to determine if bioreactors would work for the type of wastewater its facility generated. That funding continued year after year as Mancl, graduate students and post-doctoral researchers ran test after test in the lab.

PlacingFineSand_2.jpg.jpeg
Workers spread fine sand in a bioreactor cell at Whitewater Processing, Inc. The sand is the heart of the wastewater treatment system: Microbes populate the surface of the sand grains to break down and remove pollutants from the water. (Photo courtesy of Ryan Kopp)

"With all of Karen's work, we knew the system would work great," Kopp said. "It was just a matter of scaling up to what we needed for commercial use."

LateralPiping.jpg.jpeg
Perforated pipes to distribute wastewater are installed on top of the sand in a bioreactor cell. (Photo courtesy of Ryan Kopp)

A bioreactor system works like this: First, the wastewater is screened to remove as much of the suspended solids as possible before it is flowed through beds of sand and gravel. Microbes quickly populate the surface of the sand grains and gravel pieces, and they feast on the organic matter, breaking it down and removing it from the water. Treated water runs clear.

In fact, before treatment, the effluent at Whitewater is measured at over 800 BOD (biological oxygen demand), the standard that regulators use to measure water pollution. Normal sewage has a BOD of about 200.

WashedGravel.jpg.jpeg
The sand and pipes are covered with gravel. Valves sit on top of the gravel to allow periodic flushing of the pipes. (Photo courtesy of Ryan Kopp)

When Whitewater's wastewater is tested after treatment, its BOD is less than 5, and it can be released directly into the Whitewater River, with the Ohio EPA's blessing.

"The EPA has been very helpful through this whole process," Kopp said. "Very patient."

Whitewater's bioreactor system covers 4 acres of land adjacent to the facility.

waterbottles.jpg
Samples of wastewater before and after treatment from a sand bioreactor system. (Photo courtesy of Karen Mancl)

"If you visit, it looks sort of like a park," Mancl said. "All you see are 12 large rectangles of gravel, and grass is all around them.

“Under the gravel are the pipes that carry the wastewater and spray it, underground, onto the sand. It's quiet, there's no odor, and even though most wastewater treatment plants aren't necessarily something you want to look at, it's not ugly. They plan to plant trees to make it even more attractive."

One of the challenges with the system is that operators must be sure the bioreactor doesn't get overwhelmed and become clogged, she said.

"If the sand was to get clogged, the research we conducted here at Ohio State shows you need to turn that filter off and let it rest, and send the wastewater to another cell," Mancl  said. "Then the microbes consume the wastes that have clogged the filter and unclog it. That takes about four months."

Mancl knows this because her lab tested it.

"The typical loading rate for a bioreactor system is about 1.5 gallons per square foot per day,” she said. “We loaded our lab system up with 6 gallons per square foot per day, and it took a year to clog the sand.

“Then we let it rest, and after four months, it worked just like a brand new filter. You just have to let the microbes work to consume the extra organic matter that clogged the sand."

The amount of wastewater generated at Whitewater requires the use of eight bioreactor cells at a time. Whitewater is building 12 cells to have the backups needed to let filters rest; eight cells are currently online and in operation.

"Two additional cells are 80 percent complete, with two more to go," Kopp said.

Another concern with wastewater is the amount of ammonia it contains.

"There's a different group of microbes that consume ammonia, and they grow more slowly,” Mancl said. “We're working with Whitewater to track that now as the new system is starting up.

“It's definitely improving, but for now they're using a backup chemical ammonia-removal system that takes the ammonia down to practically nothing. And, the system also has some standby lagoons, so if for some reason they're not able to discharge into the stream, they can hold the water in a lagoon."

Yet another concern regarding wastewater is its level of nutrients, such as phosphorus and nitrogen. Although currently there are no limits on nutrients in treated wastewater, such regulations are definitely on the horizon, Mancl said.

"We're not just waiting to see what will happen, we're trying to get out ahead," she said.

In research funded by the Ohio Water Development Authority, one of Mancl's graduate students is using Whitewater's treated wastewater to irrigate greenhouse plants, essentially recycling the nutrients to fertilize flowers, grasses and other horticultural products.

If results are positive, Mancl and Kopp can envision a day when greenhouses could be built on top of the bioreactors or on another nearby three acres.

Another challenge is the maintenance of the pipes, pumps, controls and valves that distribute the wastewater.

"Distributing wastewater over such a large area in a simple way really hasn't been done before," Mancl said. "The technology and the types of valves we're using we're using are new. It's a new approach."

Both Kopp and Mancl believe such a system could work well at other food-related processing facilities.

"But I think we were the perfect place to build the first one," Kopp said. "There's a gravel pit that sits right behind the facility.

“The land we're using was previously a junkyard that we just had to clean up. Everything was right here. If you're farther away from gravel or in a setting without acreage, it would be more of a challenge."

But Kopp is a big believer in the system, and in Mancl herself.

Sand bioreactor size was a big question and Mancl's research helped Ohio EPA understand how big the system needed to be. Since most wastewater treatment systems need full redundancy to provide reserve capacity in case of short-term large flows or mechanical problems, EPA initially told Whitewater it needed to build 16 bioreactor cells instead of the 12 they had planned.

However, Mancl held an OSU Extension workshop on the sand bioreactor system for EPA engineers that presented all of the research on this new technology. The information gave the regulators the assurance that this different type of system provided the safeguards necessary to protect Ohio’s environment.

By reducing the number of cells from 16 to 12, Whitewater saved $250,000 in construction costs.

"That's the kind of savings that university research can provide," Mancl said.

Anyone interested in learning more and getting a closeup look at Whitewater's facility can sign up for a Cincinnati-area conference Mancl is organizing on April 11-12, 2013.

"Low-cost Treatment of Meat Processing Wastewater" is the topic of her annual 2013 Water Quality and Waste Management Conference. Registration is $200 before April 1. Details and online registration are available at http://setll.osu.edu/programs/owqwm_conf.html.

-30-


Writers

Martha Filipic
614-292-9833
filipic.3@osu.edu

Sources

Karen Mancl
614-292-4505
mancl.1@osu.edu

Ryan Kopp
513-367-4133
ryan.kopp@gmail.com

My OSU Extension
Dan Crouse

“What I've learned in this process is that marketing is everything. Business Retention & Expansion has helped debunk a lot of downtown perceptions that have stifled economic growth.”

Dan Crouse
Warren, Ohio

Signature Programs

Signature Programs

 

Ohio State University Extension embraces human diversity and is committed to ensuring that all research and related educational programs are available to clientele on a nondiscriminatory basis without regard to age, ancestry, color, disability, gender identity or expression, genetic information, HIV/AIDS status, military status, national origin, race, religion, sex, sexual orientation, or veteran status. This statement is in accordance with United States Civil Rights Laws and the USDA.

Keith L. Smith, Associate Vice President for Agricultural Administration; Associate Dean, College of Food, Agricultural, and Environmental Sciences; Director, Ohio State University Extension; and Gist Chair in Extension Education and Leadership.

For Deaf and Hard of Hearing, please contact Ohio State University Extension using your preferred communication (e-mail, relay services, or video relay services). Phone 1-800-750-0750 between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. EST Monday through Friday. Inform the operator to dial 614-292-6181.